How to Completely Repair The US Democratic System
By James Quillian, Economist, Political Analyst, Natural Law
A typical two-year Congress sees roughly 10,000 to 20,000 bills introduced, which works out to about 5,000 to 10,000 bills per year. The breakdown tells the real story:
-
Bills introduced: ~5,000 to 10,000 per year
-
Recorded congressional votes: ~850 to 1,000 per year
-
Bills that actually become law: ~135 to 250 per year
Very few bills are actually written personally by the elected member whose name is on them. The distinction is important. In theory, legislation is drafted by:
-
Congressional staff.
-
Committee staff.
-
The House or Senate Office of Legislative Counsel (specialized attorneys who convert ideas into legal language).
-
Executive branch agencies.
-
Outside groups, trade associations, and lobbyists who provide proposed text.
In practice, source number five is the origin of virtually all substantive content in modern legislation.
Outside of major executive or congressional offices, voters do not even recognize the names of other candidates on the ballot. Given these facts, democracy does not work as intended. It accomplishes the exact opposite. The result is fascism—rule by private interest groups and centralized corporate power hiding behind a hollowed-out electoral facade.
The remedy is straightforward, and the institutional blueprint already exists. As a democratic mechanism, the jury system works remarkably well.
We must establish—hopefully via a constitutional amendment—a large citizen’s jury, perhaps numbering 1,000 members, tasked with approving or disapproving every bill passed by Congress. Is the bill constitutional? Does it provide a net benefit to society overall? Such a jury can perform many other vital tasks as well, such as reviewing existing laws on the books and applying the exact same criteria to clean out the regulatory code.
Are citizens too inept to accomplish this successfully? As it is, ordinary citizens handle life and death issues, complicated medical evidence, and national security questions every day on juries with competence and care.
Here is how the selection process should work: Send out a public notice that jurors are needed and that the service pays more than most participants currently make in their regular jobs. Citizens may submit their names, and juries are picked randomly from that active applicant pool.
With this single change, the powerful lobbyist system that currently enslaves the citizenry would be permanently defused.